ReviewReviewReviewReviewReviewPerfume: The Story of a MurdererApr 20, '08 8:46 PM
for everyone
Category:Books
Genre: Literature & Fiction
Author:Patrick Suskind
Nona Schanowski sent me a book last year that I loved reading – Perfume by Patrick Suskind. I had been itching to write a review about it, but could not quite put my finger to it.

Recently, Marie (ellafitz) posted a review of the film version and finally, a comment by Faith (faitherasmo) unleashed the review that had been percolating in my mind. Here it is:

'As for being a "murderer", I personally don't think he is. It was out of his "control".' – faitherasmo

The term "murderer" connotes a whole morality system of the human species. Like, could a lioness hunting her prey be called a murderer? Or a cat stalking a bird or mouse and playing with it till it dies?

My take on Perfume is this: that there is a very thin line that separates the whole human society from the animal world that operates on base instincts. The novel's protagonist Grenouille is a human aberration because he lived his life like an animal, surviving in the unkind society he moved in through the use of a base instinct – his keen sense of smell. Ironically, he himself had no smell at all, thereby making his fellow humans (who depended on their animal sense of smell to validate their feelings) either suspicious, indifferent or downright aggressive towards him.

Grenouille never experienced loving kindness, thus he was incapable of giving it, too. And yet, he desired the scent that seemed to make humans respond with love.

The penultimate orgy scene, wherein Grenouille was seen by the people as lovable (after he had doused himself with the scent he concocted from the many lovable/lovely girls he had killed), served to show that humans still basically operate on animal instincts. The crowd's sense of morality gets thrown out the window when their sense of smell made them adore and love the convicted murderer Grenouille.

Then, the final scene wherein Grenouille makes for himself a scent that aroused in the people who smelled it an intense desire to have for themselves the source of the smell (an analogy for the feeling of love is the need to have for one's self the object of desire), shows how it was still the very human need for love that ultimately revealed Grenouille's humanity.


17 CommentsChronological   Reverse   Threaded
louellaalix wrote on Apr 20
Guia, I don't want to read the review because I want to read the book first! Last Chjristmas, this was the Christmas gift Jeff (Maia's husband) asked for. I couldn't find it in Fully Booked(naubusan sila) so I just gave Jeff a gift certificate from said bookstore. They promised to phone him as soon as it's available. And they did a month after.

gwiz wrote on Apr 20
Dali, bsahin mo na, Loy. It is a very moving and intellectually titillating read.
louellaalix wrote on Apr 20
I'll have to borrow Jeff's copy first! There's none here in the teeny weeny PowerBooks we have in SM-Cebu.
ellafitz wrote on Apr 20
excellent point raised tita gwiz

louellaalix subukan nyo po ang booksale. i got my copy there for only 70 pesos. it was a good copy too =)
louellaalix wrote on Apr 21
Where o where was this branch of Booksale?! I just rummaged through the one in Harrison Plaza and lately in SM Cebu. I got Tracy Chevalier's The Lady and the Unicorn for a hundred though! I also found Savage Beauty (biography of Edna Sty.Vincent Millay) by Nancy Milford. But no Perfume. Sad.
ellafitz wrote on Apr 21
i cant recall. probably cubao since there are at least 3 branches in the commercial area. with booksale swertihan at tiyaga talaga. harrison is a good branch too. i found my alex shakar's book of shorts
http://www.alexshakar.com/cil.htm
there for only 50 pesos =)
bubu34 wrote on Apr 21
kung may uuwi next, like Jack, I would send another copy of this..maraming publications..especially in Amazon 2nd hand they sell for so low prices..

I couldn't imagine this novel as filmed, cause "smell" is so abtract to project, but with Dustin Hoffman in the film it does make it pop! Joke lang..the director was very keen into making this a film, the orgie at the end is something that takes courage to show..the book's been published since 25 years or more..becoming a part of literary objects in schools in Germany..

sometimes, when Arno and I talk about essence of the story..we think at times taht one could have different takes on this..yours Guia is with the sensible take :) ang galing mo talaga..and one could say, there is really nothing into this story, just a plain let go of ones imagination..if you know what I mean..

"My take on Perfume is this: that there is a very thin line that separates the whole human society from the animal world that operates on base instincts. The novel's protagonist Grenouille is a human aberration because he lived his life like an animal, surviving in the unkind society he moved in through the use of a base instinct – his keen sense of smell. Ironically, he himself had no smell at all.." I find this a very realistic account..

One woman told me that for her, that he didnn't have his own "smell" is paralleled to being nothing in the society..
hugzone wrote on Apr 21
Ano ba ini? : ) Magkaiba kasi kami ng taste ng libro ni Gwiz. She is more into Carson McCullers, Thomas Hardy kind. Eh mababaw lang ang kaligayahan ko. This is rather ironic because when it comes to movies, she'd rather watch feel good movies than, say, Hannibal.
louellaalix wrote on Apr 21
Ay naku, I too like murder/mystery books and I like my movies light and "eel good" too.Who would want to see Hannibal aber?! Ikaw at si Rudy I know. The movies are for entertainment, di ba? Suspension of reality ika nga, so we watch feel good movies! he he he
bubu34 wrote on Apr 22, edited on Apr 22
Hugz, ibang murderer siya, no blood to see in this film, if I remember right...

There was a review I read about this story and Grenouille was analyzed to be "autistic"..pwede rin di ba? maraming autistic who have extreme talents in certain fields...
bubu34 wrote on Apr 22, edited on Apr 22
ellafitz wrote on Apr 22
wow so ms bubu34 you saw the film already! cool!
bubu34 wrote on Apr 22
wow so ms bubu34 you saw the film already! cool!
Marie, the film was megahit last year, here, kasi nga the book was bestseller in the 70's pa..Patrick Süskind or Sueskind ( if no umlaut sa tiklado, heheeh) is a unique German author..
meannlim wrote on Apr 23
with all the books lined up on my side table....hmm...mukhang hahanapin ko ata ang perfume na ito!
ellafitz wrote on Apr 23, edited on Apr 23
i also read that it's the most expensive german film production to date. is this true?
ellafitz wrote on Apr 23
its worth it. its a pageturner. ill lend you my copy when we meet (overdue na nga pala ang date natin!)
faitherasmo wrote on Apr 26
bubu34 said
I couldn't imagine this novel as filmed, cause "smell" is so abtract to project
Exactly. I need to see how the film is!
Add a Comment
How would you rate this book? (optional)
   
© 2008 Multiply, Inc.    About · Blog · Terms · Privacy · Corp Info · Contact Us · Help

Template design - Copyright © 2005 sonnenvogel.com All rights reserved.